MoreCannons v. bom2005: Difference between revisions

From GustapoTown
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 33: Line 33:
Although a courthouse was built in March 2020, there was no such building at the time. [[Choco Valley]] was the only civilized city-state established, and players agreed it was a neutral ground to host the trial. [[PlasmaFireBlast]], the mayor of Choco Valley, was offline when this decision was made. However, he joined the server halfway through the case and approved of the idea. There was no agreement of how the justice system worked, since there was no formal legislation about imprisonment, execution, or any other form of punishment.
Although a courthouse was built in March 2020, there was no such building at the time. [[Choco Valley]] was the only civilized city-state established, and players agreed it was a neutral ground to host the trial. [[PlasmaFireBlast]], the mayor of Choco Valley, was offline when this decision was made. However, he joined the server halfway through the case and approved of the idea. There was no agreement of how the justice system worked, since there was no formal legislation about imprisonment, execution, or any other form of punishment.


GenghisKhanor was a respected member of the server, holding various leadership roles on previous Minecraft and Discord servers. MoreCannons and bom2005 both agreed to appoint him as their judge. Both MoreCannons and bom2005 also had an unspoken agreement to represent themselves in court. The lack of players during this early stage of the server caused a juror shortage; with the exception of audience member [[Scrubdaddy17]] who could not join voice chat, all online players were assumed to be a juror. This would prove to be problematic, since CaptainRay was in bom2005's mafia, and critter660 never planned to vote.
GenghisKhanor was a respected member of the server, holding various leadership roles on previous Minecraft and Discord servers. MoreCannons and bom2005 both agreed to appoint him as their judge, possibly after he volunteered. Both MoreCannons and bom2005 also had an unspoken agreement to represent themselves in court. The lack of players during this early stage of the server caused a juror shortage; with the exception of audience member [[Scrubdaddy17]] who could not join voice chat, all online players were assumed to be a juror. This would prove to be problematic, since CaptainRay was in bom2005's mafia, and critter660 never planned to vote.


== Trial ==
== Trial ==

Revision as of 21:17, 29 March 2023

MoreCannons v. bom2005
MoreCannons (left) and bom2005
Time February 11th, 2020, approx. 19:00 - 20:30
Location Choco Valley
Key players MoreCannons (prosecutor), bom2005 (accused), GenghisKhanor (judge)
Jury _OverPixel_, CaptainRay, critter660 (disputed)
Verdict Acquittal

MoreCannons v. bom2005 was the first and only court case on Gustapo Town I, taking place on February 11th, 2020. Earlier that day, MoreCannons died after falling off a roof and blamed bom2005 for pushing him. bom2005 denied the accusations, claiming it was an effort to defame him and his mafia. The trial was hastily formed, with both players representing themselves in court and assigning GenghisKhanor as judge. All accusations relied on hearsay, and members of the jury were biased or disputed.

The case is often considered the first historical event of the server. GenghisKhanor controversially acquitted bom2005, leading to lasting conspiracies and distrust in the government that defined the Age of Politics. The case also spotlighted the mafia as an interfering force on the server for the first time, igniting a month-long rivalry between the syndicate and anti-mafia activists.

Background

MoreCannons was an aspiring politician, hoping to establish a government with himself as supreme lawmaker. Throughout early February, he half-jokingly declared taxes on all citizens. MoreCannons assured he would also pay taxes yet also hoped to be the private tax collector. These proposals to heavily tax other players into possible bankruptcy were very unpopular and diminished his reputation. He was simultaneously hoping to create a railroad network between residencies under a monopoly later called Wandel Transportation Corporation. However, he also hoped to place unreasonable tolls on tracks and forcefully eliminate all other forms of travel. MoreCannons never implemented these measures.

bom2005 was one of the players who opposed MoreCannons' hunger for power. Being a prominent player on previous Minecraft servers, he supported a free market, advocating for the implementation of a basic rulebook without politics or taxation. bom2005 established a mafia known as "Crime Incorporated" with the only other member at the time being CaptainRay. The mafia had not yet accomplished anything before the case, but conspiracy theorists believe the mafia's involvement in the court case was prominent.

Unlike proto-politicians on the server, bom2005 pursued wealth more than political power. He was known to have diamond gear before MoreCannons even collected iron. This could have potentially allowed bom2005 to more severely harm MoreCannons during assault.

Incident

Upon resurfacing, MoreCannons took this scenic photo on his way back to Jolby Beach at 18:14:41. This is the last photo he took before his death.

On February 11th, 2020, MoreCannons went on a rant defending his taxation policies to the dismay of his listeners, proposing the "Buffoon Tax," the "Unfunny Tax," and the "Tax Tax." He was on a lengthy mining trip and re-surfaced at approximately 18:10. He took many scenic photos on his return journey to Jolby Beach from 18:12 to 18:14, before reaching his unfinished home at around 18:15. At the time, only the basement and first floor without a ceiling existed. The roof area was easily accessible. Nobody else was at the city-state, including resident critter660.

MoreCannons returned to work on construction of his house. He claimed that after a few minutes, bom2005 arrived at Jolby Beach with full diamond gear. A couple minutes after bom2005's supposed arrival to Jolby Beach, MoreCannons fell off his roof and died. He was at one heart before falling off the five-block ledge, and the death message merely stated he "fell from a high place." MoreCannons reasoned his low health was due to bom2005's continuous assault before the murder. After respawning, MoreCannons angrily blamed bom2005 for his death which bom2005 immediately denied. Within approximately twenty to forty minutes, court arrangements were made.

Setup

Although a courthouse was built in March 2020, there was no such building at the time. Choco Valley was the only civilized city-state established, and players agreed it was a neutral ground to host the trial. PlasmaFireBlast, the mayor of Choco Valley, was offline when this decision was made. However, he joined the server halfway through the case and approved of the idea. There was no agreement of how the justice system worked, since there was no formal legislation about imprisonment, execution, or any other form of punishment.

GenghisKhanor was a respected member of the server, holding various leadership roles on previous Minecraft and Discord servers. MoreCannons and bom2005 both agreed to appoint him as their judge, possibly after he volunteered. Both MoreCannons and bom2005 also had an unspoken agreement to represent themselves in court. The lack of players during this early stage of the server caused a juror shortage; with the exception of audience member Scrubdaddy17 who could not join voice chat, all online players were assumed to be a juror. This would prove to be problematic, since CaptainRay was in bom2005's mafia, and critter660 never planned to vote.

Trial

These makeshift tables and chairs inside PlasmaFireBlast's home hosted the trial. By MoreCannons (12 Mar. 2020).

The trial began at around 19:00. GenghisKhanor allowed MoreCannons to begin his testimony. MoreCannons claimed he was peacefully constructing his home when bom2005 started assaulting him without reason. In his version of the incident, bom2005 purposefully shoved him off the roof to murder him. bom2005 immediately denied these claims, stating he was not present at Jolby Beach and was at his home-base Old Zealand. He correctly pointed out it was raining at the moment of death, and this weather could have caused MoreCannons to slip off his roof. bom2005 also accused MoreCannons of attempting to defame the mafia, an organization that MoreCannons was audibly not fond of.

Before the trial started, no agreement was made on how evidence was to be presented. MoreCannons possessed logs and leaves from the construction site as evidence which he claimed had bom2005's trace. bom2005 was only aware of MoreCannons having logs and demanded to use all of them for counter-evidence. MoreCannons sneakily gave him only a couple logs out of his large stash, claiming they were all the logs he had. MoreCannons presented his evidence; GenghisKhanor dismissed the theory about bom2005's trace but confirmed the blocks matched the design of MoreCannons' house and aided the construction narrative. bom2005 exclaimed the logs he was given had MoreCannons' initials on it which GenghisKhanor denied seeing.

MoreCannons also called various players to the stand for their testimonies:

  • MoreCannons questioned _OverPixel_ where he was during the incident despite having no involvement with it.
  • MoreCannons questioned bom2005 himself what happened; he predictably denied the accusations again.
  • MoreCannons questioned GenghisKhanor who was going to win the case; GenghisKhanor responded he can not reveal said information.

These testimonies were ultimately useless, and many believe MoreCannons simply used them out of hysteria. Afterwards, MoreCannons exclaimed "I don't want bom2005 arrested. I don't even want an apology from him. I just want him executed. I want to push him off my roof!"

Disorderly behavior

The trial was disorganized, causing mass mayhem in PlasmaFireBlast's property. _OverPixel_ and critter660 rode boats down PlasmaFireBlast's basement stairs, and both MoreCannons and bom2005 would disrupt the trial to join the rides. When PlasmaFireBlast joined the server, he feared his house would get vandalized and started violently chasing jurors. _OverPixel_ was murdered by an unknown assailant outside the home for being disruptive. GenghisKhanor threatened to kill jurors with his gavel (an axe) for being annoying, and he accidentally murdered MoreCannons while wildly swinging. Strangely, nobody was punished for these murders, and the trial continued without their acknowledgement.

Jury vote

After all of the evidence was presented, GenghisKhanor requested only jurors join him in a separate Discord voice channel. Their final decision is the major subject of controversy, with opposing understandings of everyone's final decisions. The two undisputed factors of the ruling are _OverPixel_'s vote to execute bom2005 and CaptainRay's vote to acquit him.

critter660's vote

In the disorganized case, jurors were not officially declared, merely assumed. critter660 joined the juror voice chat and was believed to be a juror, yet he did not declare himself one. critter660 was therefore not allowed to enter the juror voice channel, with GenghisKhanor demanding only jurors join the call. He left the voice channel before voting, leaving the decision split. GenghisKhanor has since blamed critter660 entirely for the case's disorganization. critter660 later said he "wouldn't have voted for [MoreCannons]." However, critter660 would collaborate frequently with MoreCannons in the future. MoreCannons has suggested critter660 intended to vote against bom2005, but his vote was disqualified due to mafia influence over the case. However, it is overall accepted critter660's failure to vote was not purposeful but merely an act of incompetence.

GenghisKhanor's tie-breaker vote

Without critter660, the jury was in a stalemate. GenghisKhanor decided to be the tie-breaking vote. This was a controversial decision, considering there was an odd amount of jurors counting critter660. PlasmaFireBlast was also present for a majority of the trial and could have been asked to settle the dispute. _OverPixel_ felt MoreCannons was cheated with GenghisKhanor exercising complete authority by effectively being a judge and juror. This led to the infamous title: "President, Pope, Judge, and Jury".

GenghisKhanor officially acquitted bom2005, citing a lack of solid proof that he murdered MoreCannons. Many players against the mafia were angered by this ruling. While it was true that there was no definite proof of bom2005's guilt, historians point to the circumstantial evidence, CaptainRay's presence in the trial despite his affiliations, and bom2005's poor defense as major factors in the outrage. Conspiracies quickly spawned that GenghisKhanor was on the mafia's payroll to acquit bom2005. An important element to acknowledge is MoreCannons' reputation as a corrupt businessman before the trial. The opposition against his excessive taxation policies could have been reflected by the jury and judge ruling against him. Historians have also noted that MoreCannons acted hysterical in court, likely weakening his defense and appearance.

Aftermath

Immediately after the trial

The in-game screenshot was taken by MoreCannons at 20:54:08, shortly after the trial. This conversation happened a month later; bom2005 (red) once again claimed he was framed.

The trial lasted around ninety minutes. After the trial, MoreCannons, GenghisKhanor, and _OverPixel_ returned home. bom2005 and CaptainRay followed MoreCannons to Jolby Beach at around 20:50 and unquestionably began harassing him. In the mayhem, MoreCannons lured bom2005 to push him off the roof once again, capturing a screenshot in mid-air. bom2005 claimed contradictory things about the photo, including it being "poto shot" (photoshopped), "fake news," and "an imposter [in the photo]." GenghisKhanor denied the chance for a re-trial. Supporters of MoreCannons have used this screenshot as evidence of bom2005's untrustworthiness and willingness to assault others.

A couple minutes after the screenshot was taken, MoreCannons was hurt down to half-a-heart. CaptainRay, while digging up some dirt, accidentally struck MoreCannons with his shovel, killing him instantly. While MoreCannons considered suing him for manslaughter, he "lost all faith in the justice system already."

Legacy

As the first source of conflict on Gustapo Town I, the case became a litmus test of beliefs and affiliations that defined the Age of Politics. MoreCannons, _OverPixel_, and PlasmaFireBlast all agreed the trial was rigged and created an informal alliance. GenghisKhanor's popularity with players outside the mafia diminished. The allowance of him to become the Federal Judge of the server was continuously disputed by his contemporaries. His unofficial position as president was often ignored by players who did not trust his decisions. The mafia's influence on GenghisKhanor is questionable; although there is no evidence of GenghisKhanor being paid by bom2005, there is reason to believe the mafia would endorse someone against MoreCannons' anti-mafia stance. bom2005 himself later stated GenghisKhanor was paid off, but later backtracked and denied it. GenghisKhanor also denied the rumor.

The case spawned the tense rivalry between bom2005's mafia and MoreCannons' anti-mafia sympathizers, spanning over a month and defining much of Gustapo Town I's history. The legitimacy of the government was also put into question. Its unpopularity was put into full display in the riot at the Choco Valley Caucuses nine days later when the government officially collapsed.

MoreCannons v. bom2005 still remains one of the most controversial events on the server. Its infamy became engrained in server history, with players completely uninvolved with the case learning the circumstances, although often without the full context of MoreCannons' tax and toll proposals or bom2005's defense. Arguments about the verdict often spawned out of nowhere, even months and years afterwards. Historians have noted the case as exemplary of the government's disorganization and prophetic of its collapse, with TheBoris21 noting the entire case relied on hearsay. The phrase "fell off the roof" and its variants transcended the actual event, turning into a server culture phenomenon with nearly every player in server history understanding the reference. Even after the server's death, people consistently joked and referenced the case out of context. Despite this attention, there has never been an agreed consensus of the truth surrounding the death. bom2005 later stated he was shocked he won the case and admitted to being completely unprepared for the trial.