"Energy Consumption Killed GT1": Difference between revisions

From GustapoTown
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 3: Line 3:
== Background ==
== Background ==


After ''Gustapo Town I'', servers created by [[Larvey]] and A_Squ4r3d were generally unsuccessful, causing widespread debate about what sustains player activity. Informal theories were thrown around for years including limiting in-game progress, preventing wealth and power gaps, and avoiding overpopulation. Many players, notably [[GenghisKhanor]] and [[Most_Unoriginal]], were vocal advocates of creating a new Minecraft server on multiple occasions from 2021 to 2022. As discussion increased again in November 2022, A_Squ4r3d sought to create the ultimate study of previous servers and find solutions to create a worthwhile successor to ''Gustapo Town I''.
After ''Gustapo Town I'', servers created by [[Larvey]] and A_Squ4r3d were generally unsuccessful, causing widespread debates about what worked with ''Gustapo Town I'' and what sustains player activity. Informal theories were thrown around for years including limiting in-game progress, preventing wealth and power gaps, and avoiding overpopulation. Many players, notably [[GenghisKhanor]] and [[Most_Unoriginal]], were vocal advocates of creating a new Minecraft server on multiple occasions from 2021 to 2022. As discussion increased again in November 2022, A_Squ4r3d sought to create the ultimate study of previous servers and find solutions to create a worthwhile successor to ''Gustapo Town I''.


== Essay ==
== Essay ==

Revision as of 21:50, 5 March 2024

"Energy Consumption Killed GT1" is the informal title of an essay by A_Squ4r3d, contesting the contemporary historical account of Gustapo Town I and theorizing what killed the server and its sequels. The essay was written from November 28th to December 21st, 2022, and became the most significant piece of Gustapo Town research not conducted by MoreCannons. It sparked the creation of Gustapolis, widely considered the most successful post-Gustapo Town server.

Background

After Gustapo Town I, servers created by Larvey and A_Squ4r3d were generally unsuccessful, causing widespread debates about what worked with Gustapo Town I and what sustains player activity. Informal theories were thrown around for years including limiting in-game progress, preventing wealth and power gaps, and avoiding overpopulation. Many players, notably GenghisKhanor and Most_Unoriginal, were vocal advocates of creating a new Minecraft server on multiple occasions from 2021 to 2022. As discussion increased again in November 2022, A_Squ4r3d sought to create the ultimate study of previous servers and find solutions to create a worthwhile successor to Gustapo Town I.

Essay

A_Squ4r3d predominantly used wiki information for sources. The essay's title includes personal information; therefore, the informal title "Energy Consumption Killed GT1" is used in this article. In the title page, A_Squ4r3d credits himself as a graduate of "Clown University's" department of philosophy.

Challenging Gustapo Town I history

MoreCannons and TheBoris21's categorization of Gustapo Town I history on top, versus A_Squ4r3d's on bottom.

A_Squ4r3d challenges the dominating categorization of Gustapo Town I eras, created by MoreCannons and TheBoris21. He argues the so-called "Age of Politics" erroneously gives too much attention to political events that were fairly insignificant to server history, citing that a majority of events within this period were the creation of city-states and businesses, not political events. As such, he insists that February 26th, 2020 - citing the End Raid that allowed acquisition of elytras and made Wandel Transportation Corporation obsolete, alongside the creation of CRIME Enterprises that focused on building automated farms - should mark the Age of Automation.

His new timeline proposes a period called the "Age of Excess" beginning in March 22nd, 2020, approximately when the Farm Committee created the Wither Rose Farm, citing the "formerly formidable End dimension being transformed into a vehicle for the redistribution of wealth, or rather, consolidation of wealth." He characterizes this period by its low player count and no new players joining, killing the server.

Causes for server deaths

Tackling the death of Gustapo Town I, A_Squ4r3d gives credit to MoreCannons' theories that the Farm Committee's secrecy and wealth contributed to non-associated players losing interest. However, A_Squ4r3d claims these non-redstone oriented players cannot absolve themselves from blame, as they made minimal effort to counter the Farm Committee's success. Instead, A_Squ4r3d conceptualizes the server's death through the concept of energy or the amount of redstone placed. Although unable to conjure real data that supports his claim, he notes the peak of server activity (which A_Squ4r3d incorrectly cites as the raid on Dresden, rather than the Battle of Choco Valley on the same day) expended little energy. Meanwhile, the construction of Farm Committee megastructures required mass amounts of said energy, perceivably lowering the player count. A_Squ4r3d believes this correlation aligns with the Kardashev scale.

A_Squ4r3d also notes that major Gustapo Town I events were caused by only a few key players, with many often unwilling to risk resources to start conflict. However, he contrasts violent events that risked in-game resources, such as the Third Battle of Chunker Hill started by mafia members, against political events like the Fake Mafia War that only risked non-physical power. Hence, A_Squ4r3d emphasizes most events should be similar to the latter that please both skilled and unskilled players.

Solutions for a future server

Relating back to energy, A_Squ4r3d claims to solve the wealth gap and playstyle compatibility by limiting the resources that enter the server economy. This levels the playing field between players, and lowers the risk of losing valuable items during events. A_Squ4r3d hopes to achieve this by keeping players close together by limiting exploration and in-game progress, although he gives credence that some exploration is still necessary for the sense of player freedom. Hence, he proposes a datapack that increases mob spawning and improves mob AI the further a player is from spawn, minimizing but not eliminating exploration. He also proposes lowering mineral spawn rates and encouraging players to organize into city-states of at least five players.

Impact and legacy

A_Squ4r3d released the first draft to MoreCannons on November 28th, 2022, and subsequently released revised versions to other players in the following days. Players generally agreed with his arguments for sustaining a server, although many were still unenthusiastic that a successful server would be created. Players, including bom2005 who historically advocated for exploration and in-game events, agreed to not pursue in-game progress on a potential future server. A_Squ4r3d later criticized his own essay, believing his concept of "energy" was unfinished.

Gustapo Town I criticism

"Energy Consumption Killed GT1" marks the first significant piece of Gustapo Town I research not conducted by MoreCannons, as well as the first published criticism of his research. MoreCannons responded against A_Squ4r3d's era categorization, stating the current "Age of Politics" is justified as the Choco Valley Caucuses and the government's subsequent collapse significantly altered the power dynamic of the server, with the Farm Committee's success being impossible without this paradigm shift. MoreCannons also justified the Age of Automation beginning with the Farm Committee's creation on March 1st, 2020, since it was the first organization entirely dedicated to engineering. However, MoreCannons conceded the "Age of Reconstruction" was imperfect and A_Squ4r3d's proposed "Age of Excess" is likely more helpful; MoreCannons claimed March 14th, 2020, should mark said era, as both the decline in server population and construction of the Witch Farm roughly began on that day.

Gustapolis

Main article: Gustapolis

In the following weeks, A_Squ4r3d enlisted the help of MoreCannons to create a datapack that followed the essay's proposals for a server. The datapack was completed on December 25th, 2022, and released on A_Squ4r3d's server Gustapolis. The server survived for over a month, and is widely considered the most successful post-Gustapo Town server, with its two major factions involved in a server-long war.