Death of Gustapo Town I: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| (2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The server ''[[Gustapo Town I]]'' is said to have '''died''' | The server ''[[Gustapo Town I]]'' is said to have '''died''' on April 8th. In the weeks prior, many long-term players became demotivated and subsequently retired, causing server activity to dwindle. This was despite an influx of new players in mid-March. Following the failure of the [[Sequel servers|sequel servers]], many theories have been proposed about the factors that caused the original server's initial success and ultimate death, in hopes of re-creating and improving upon its success with a future server. | ||
== Background == | == Background == | ||
[[File: | [[File:Badphoto.jpg|thumb|This low-quality photo taken by A_Squ4r3d on April 8th, 2020 at 15:25 is the last piece of evidence of playtime on ''Gustapo Town I''.]] | ||
Between late February and mid-early March 2020, players [[Green Tea Grotto#LondieOwO|LondieOwO]], [[Green Tea Grotto#Splatterpaint |Splatterpaint]], and [[C0baltian]] retired; [[GenghisKhanor]] was on an indefinite hiatus; and [[critter660]] and server founder [[PlasmaFireBlast]] seemed to be decreasingly online. There was a universal, unspoken concern that the server would die from player inactivity. As such, the [[Farm Committee]] heralded the construction of a [[Farm Committee#Spawn city|spawn marketplace]], in hopes of keeping the playerbase active and connected via server economy. | Between late February and mid-early March 2020, players [[Green Tea Grotto#LondieOwO|LondieOwO]], [[Green Tea Grotto#Splatterpaint |Splatterpaint]], and [[C0baltian]] retired; [[GenghisKhanor]] was on an indefinite hiatus; and [[critter660]] and server founder [[PlasmaFireBlast]] seemed to be decreasingly online. There was a universal, unspoken concern that the server would die from player inactivity. As such, the [[Farm Committee]] heralded the construction of a [[Farm Committee#Spawn city|spawn marketplace]], in hopes of keeping the playerbase active and connected via server economy. | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
It is important to note that little in-game progress was made during the [[Gustapo Town I#Age of Politics|Age of Politics]], as a majority of players spent their time dealing with building a government and corporations. Its major purveyors, including PlasmaFireBlast, GenghisKhanor, and [[MoreCannons]], were not particularly skilled at the game. Once the government collapsed and there was not a clear goal, players began focusing much more on in-game progress. The original ''Gustapo Town II'' server, dedicated to working on automated farms, died very quickly as a partial result of quickly accelerating through game milestones. | It is important to note that little in-game progress was made during the [[Gustapo Town I#Age of Politics|Age of Politics]], as a majority of players spent their time dealing with building a government and corporations. Its major purveyors, including PlasmaFireBlast, GenghisKhanor, and [[MoreCannons]], were not particularly skilled at the game. Once the government collapsed and there was not a clear goal, players began focusing much more on in-game progress. The original ''Gustapo Town II'' server, dedicated to working on automated farms, died very quickly as a partial result of quickly accelerating through game milestones. | ||
Most players, involved with ''Gustapo Town I'' or not, have agreed that this is a major factor behind server longevity, and have agreed to complete major in-game milestones with large communal events. MoreCannons has particularly suggested to slow down in-game progression as much as possible to prolong activity with politics, economies, or other implemented institutions. However, some more-skilled players like bom2005 have rejected this belief, finding those actions boring and | Most players, involved with ''Gustapo Town I'' or not, have agreed that this is a major factor behind server longevity, and have agreed to complete major in-game milestones with large communal events. MoreCannons has particularly suggested to slow down in-game progression as much as possible to prolong activity with politics, economies, or other implemented institutions. However, some more-skilled players like bom2005 have rejected this belief, finding those actions boring and preferring focus on in-game milestones. | ||
=== Lack of notable events === | === Lack of notable events === | ||
| Line 53: | Line 53: | ||
[[File:Screen Shot 2021-02-03 at 1.10.31 PM.png|thumb|On February 29th, 2020, bom2005 (blue) declared all farms created by Crime Canyon engineers have a one-time fee. There was clear outrage from this announcement.]] | [[File:Screen Shot 2021-02-03 at 1.10.31 PM.png|thumb|On February 29th, 2020, bom2005 (blue) declared all farms created by Crime Canyon engineers have a one-time fee. There was clear outrage from this announcement.]] | ||
Larvey acknowledged this factor and decided to make the original ''Gustapo Town II'' server as a small, cooperative community to create automated farms. Still, casual players slipped through and wanted a server that recaptured the freedom of the previous server. ''[[Sequel servers#Gustapo Town III|Gustapo Town III]]'' was the | Larvey acknowledged this factor and decided to make the original ''Gustapo Town II'' server as a small, cooperative community to create automated farms. Still, casual players slipped through and wanted a server that recaptured the freedom of the previous server. ''[[Sequel servers#Gustapo Town III|Gustapo Town III]]'' was the complete opposite, being a government-based server that unified "empires." However, bom2005, alongside some personal friends not on the previous servers, created an anarchy group completely separate from the others, once again hurting the prospect of universality. | ||
=== Wealth and power gap === | === Wealth and power gap === | ||
Latest revision as of 06:12, 2 July 2026
The server Gustapo Town I is said to have died on April 8th. In the weeks prior, many long-term players became demotivated and subsequently retired, causing server activity to dwindle. This was despite an influx of new players in mid-March. Following the failure of the sequel servers, many theories have been proposed about the factors that caused the original server's initial success and ultimate death, in hopes of re-creating and improving upon its success with a future server.
Background

Between late February and mid-early March 2020, players LondieOwO, Splatterpaint, and C0baltian retired; GenghisKhanor was on an indefinite hiatus; and critter660 and server founder PlasmaFireBlast seemed to be decreasingly online. There was a universal, unspoken concern that the server would die from player inactivity. As such, the Farm Committee heralded the construction of a spawn marketplace, in hopes of keeping the playerbase active and connected via server economy.
These concerns were temporarily halted on March 13th, 2020, when the COVID-19 pandemic officially cancelled school, inadvertently bringing an influx of new players to the server. The following day, the server reached its concurrent player record of 17 players, immediately before the Battle of Choco Valley. Additionally, GenghisKhanor returned to help with the spawn city. Many players believed this was a positive sign of the server maintaining prolonged popularity.

Despite these measures, the player count would continue to decrease; critter660, GenghisKhanor, TheFlawlessGem, RoseDraws, and possibly SirMrSire retired on March 14th, and PlasmaFireBlast retired the following day. Since the server was in late-game Minecraft, the immediate consensus was that players were demotivated by the lack of available events or projects. The spawn city was never finished, as prices were too high to draw in a substantial amount of customers. Newer players were also less interested in older history and players, focusing on their personal city-states and businesses that were often far away from spawn. This exacerbated the separation between players and playstyles that destroyed any sense of server unity. Some Farm Committee members were convinced that the 1.16 update would motivate players to return and explore the nether; the server died before the update was released in June.
After the completion of the Witch Farm on April 1st, the only confirmed remaining active players were Scrubdaddy17, conman0613, and the five founding members of the Farm Committee. The Farm Committee turned their attention to the P.I.S.S. project; according to Most_Unoriginal, P.I.S.S. was intended to be created by a new group and hence not be associated with the Farm Committee. However, due to the small player count, every engineer involved was a Farm Committee group member, deeming this motive irrelevant. The group only partially completed the shuttle. The end of the station's construction officially marked the death of the server, no earlier than April 3rd.
Theories
Even months and years after the death of Gustapo Town I, discussions have arose about what caused its death, in hopes of avoiding the same mistakes and replicating its success with a new server. It is generally agreed that it was some combination of the factors below.
All major events accomplished

Both GenghisKhanor and PlasmaFireBlast stated that they believed everything in-game had already been accomplished. The Enderdragon was killed during the End Raid on February 26th, and nearly every player had diamond gear and elytras by mid-March. Many players had discovered and looted treasure chests, bom2005 found a woodland mansion in late February, and Crime Canyon engineers killed the Wither multiple times. Besides the End Raid, most of these accomplishments were not in communal events, instead being achieved sporadically and independently. The only aspect within the game not explored in-depth was the nether dimension, as server owner Larvey discouraged players from exploring the dimension and loading new chunks in preparation for the 1.16 update. Larvey also reset the end cities on March 27th to encourage more exploration and looting, but this action was ultimately inconsequential.
Arguably every event and project during the Age of Automation was artificially initiated to keep momentum within the server. This included spawning raids on city-states and building increasingly large megastructures. However, many players, particularly those who were less skilled and experienced, were generally demotivated to continue playing. Additionally, players who joined the server later on were likely discouraged, since valuable gear was often donated or sold to them early on, allowing minimal room to progress legitimately.
It is important to note that little in-game progress was made during the Age of Politics, as a majority of players spent their time dealing with building a government and corporations. Its major purveyors, including PlasmaFireBlast, GenghisKhanor, and MoreCannons, were not particularly skilled at the game. Once the government collapsed and there was not a clear goal, players began focusing much more on in-game progress. The original Gustapo Town II server, dedicated to working on automated farms, died very quickly as a partial result of quickly accelerating through game milestones.
Most players, involved with Gustapo Town I or not, have agreed that this is a major factor behind server longevity, and have agreed to complete major in-game milestones with large communal events. MoreCannons has particularly suggested to slow down in-game progression as much as possible to prolong activity with politics, economies, or other implemented institutions. However, some more-skilled players like bom2005 have rejected this belief, finding those actions boring and preferring focus on in-game milestones.
Lack of notable events
Theorized by MoreCannons, he argues that Gustapo Town I sustained popularity through historical, communal events unassociated with in-game progress. Political events like the MoreCannons v. bom2005 case, the Fake Mafia War, and the Weeb Assassinations kept interest and debate within the playerbase. Additionally, the persistence of city-states like Choco Valley or businesses like Wandel Transportation Corporation established a sort of long-term server lore that helped maintain a universal feel. In this theory, focusing on individual builds and megastructures are not helpful with maintaining an evolving "plot line." MoreCannons particularly endorses competitive events that involve active engagement between players and factions.
This theory has been criticized by bom2005 who argued the opposite: creating a government and restrictive rules takes away freedom and interest. It is also difficult to account for genuineness, as events like the Third Battle of Chunker Hill or the Battle of Choco Valley were partially started to create content for the wiki, rather than happening naturally.

Overpopulation
Some players have suggested that the influx of new players from the COVID-19 pandemic had the opposite effect of killing Gustapo Town I faster. A majority of these newcomers were outsiders to the core friend group of the "KWOYG" Discord server and had little interest in the affairs and history of long-term players. The overpopulation theory suggests that a server bounded by a close-knit community survives much longer than one reliant on various dependent players and factions. Notably, PlasmaFireBlast initially created the server only for his closest friends, and its population gradually increased over the following weeks. In contrast, sequel servers opened by A_Squ4r3d from 2020 to 2021 were publicly announced and opened to a large group of ~15-20 players, likely burning interest extremely quickly; the exception was a private server hosted by A_Squ4r3d and only open to CaptainRay and MoreCannons. Of these, this server was arguably the most successful as they built a communal house for themselves and remained as a cooperative unit.
Others have speculated that overpopulation accidentally leads to players being too spread out. After the influx of new players, many of them established city-states extremely far away from spawn. Additionally, the Farm Committee built their automated farms thousands of blocks apart. The only feasible way of reaching many of these locations from spawn was through nether highways, but these were not well built or clearly labeled. One of A_Squ4r3d's servers attempted to accommodate this with a small, custom-made map, but this arguably ruined the aspect of exploration.
Playstyle incompatibility
Possibly exacerbated by overpopulation, the difference in playstyles between players possibly waned universal interest in Gustapo Town I. PlasmaFireBlast and other early players initially designed the server to focus on political and economical affairs, bordering on a roleplay parody of the 2020 election cycle. However, bom2005 and CaptainRay were among the first players that rejected this playstyle, focusing on collecting resources and ignoring the political implications of their actions. After the Choco Valley Caucuses, bom2005 vocalized his distaste for the government system and preference for a simplistic rulebook over a constitution; CaptainRay followed suit by stating politics were killing the server and the main focus had to be gameplay. Players attached to city-states and businesses without automated farms drifted increasingly further apart from those who lived nomadically and focused on exploration or automation.
Additionally, the incompatibility in playstyles separated groups and players further apart. The difference between traditional and technological playstyles was most prevalent in Crime Canyon. TheBoris21, who enjoyed the prospect of a government and had no automation experience, was disappointed by the mafia's transformation of his home into a playground for engineers; while these engineers grouped together to form the Farm Committee, TheBoris21 was left behind and lost motivation, retiring from the server in mid-March. The Farm Committee was particularly insistent on forging an independent identity, creating a separate group chat and voice channel for themselves, while building far away from pre-established locations; MoreCannons argued, "when the Farm Committee made their own group chat, it split up the playerbase too much and ruined the unity between playstyles."

Larvey acknowledged this factor and decided to make the original Gustapo Town II server as a small, cooperative community to create automated farms. Still, casual players slipped through and wanted a server that recaptured the freedom of the previous server. Gustapo Town III was the complete opposite, being a government-based server that unified "empires." However, bom2005, alongside some personal friends not on the previous servers, created an anarchy group completely separate from the others, once again hurting the prospect of universality.
Wealth and power gap
Primarily endorsed by MoreCannons, PlasmaFireBlast, TheBoris21, GenghisKhanor, and LondieOwO, the theory states that the Farm Committee's actions increased wealth and power disparity that discouraged players unassociated with the group.
On February 16th, 2020, bom2005 threatened to inflate the iron and gold economies with automated farms. This prospect horrified non-redstone oriented players who feared that they could never realistically compete. Following the government's collapse, automation grew increasingly prevalent, and players with automated farms predictably became the richest players on the server. However, Crime Canyon engineers (who later became the Farm Committee) united to build the largest automated farms on the server. While Most_Unoriginal claimed they built "farms that anyone can use," members decided to make a majority of their farms private to themselves, with others requiring one-time fees. The Farm Committee's later actions attempted to foster more universal community with a spawn city, but it further increased the wealth of the Farm Committee. All profits from the shops went directly to the engineers, already the richest players on the server. Prices were considerably high, particularly a beacon costing 50 diamonds; even though the cost was proportionally understandable, it was still too expensive for potential buyers, and the group gave away beacons to new players for free under IOUs.
Despite these criticisms, many newer players were quite wealthy, either through subsidies from the Farm Committee or building personal automated farms. Nevertheless, players uninterested or unfamiliar with automation were unable to compete.
It is important to note these criticisms are somewhat hypocritical, as there were previous attempts by many early players to seize power politically, to the detriment of other players. Some of the founding engineers have defended the group profusely by claiming their critics were only projecting their personal failures. Nevertheless, debates have continued on how automation should be handled; PlasmaFireBlast suggested banning it entirely, while others suggest enforcing government limitations.
Effect of COVID-19
Gustapo Town I was started during February 2020, while every member was together in the same school. The theory notes that the COVID-19 pandemic started as a blessing that allowed players to entirely focus on the server, bringing an unprecedented wave of enthusiasm. bom2005 argues that this was crucial to the success of the original server, and those specific conditions will never be replicated again. However, this initial boost in popularity and absolute dedication on the server caused much quicker burnout, resulting in the server dying mere weeks after its peak in concurrent players activity.
Energy consumption
See also: "Energy Consumption Killed GT1"
A_Squ4r3d outlined an essay that claims energy, or amount of redstone placed, inversely correlates to player activity and enthusiasm. He noted the peak of server activity (which A_Squ4r3d incorrectly cited as the raid on Dresden, rather than the Battle of Choco Valley on the same day) expended little energy. Meanwhile, the construction of Farm Committee megastructures required mass amounts of said energy, perceivably lowering the player count. A_Squ4r3d believes this correlation aligns with the Kardashev scale.
A_Squ4r3d proposed limiting the resources that enter the server economy, theoretically leveling the playing field between players and lowering the risk of losing valuable items during events. A_Squ4r3d hoped to achieve this by keeping players close together by limiting exploration and in-game progress, proposing a datapack that increased mob spawning and improves mob AI the further a player is from spawn. This concept was used in the creation of the fairly successful Gustapolis server.